The Tracing Floor · knowledge tree

The Four-Realm Knowledge Tree

Every subject a school or university teaches can be located on this tree, and its location shows which dependencies beneath it go untaught.

Four nested realms, the base at the centre; the formal sciences running through all of them; one open slot above. Pick a subject to see what it leaves out, or trace one of the platform's own modules.

Draft 0.1 for the author's review. The placements, the dependency reasons and the module traces are the author's framework reading.

The whole tree, as a list

The same tree in reading order, from the summit down. Open a cycle to see its sub-cycles and elements.

Realm 4 · The summitCivilisationalEverything humans make and keep making: institutions, technologies, languages, laws, markets, arts and beliefs. Full reflexive agency, maximal capability, minimal stability.
The information meta-cycle Knownmeta-cycleElemental

How a civilisation produces, encodes, transmits, stores and validates its representations of itself and the world.

The framework's thesis It is the meta-cycle: every other civilisational cycle runs on it, so corrupting it decays all of them. Imagined · framework

Depends on

Inquiry and observationOrganisedScientific research · Observation and measurement · Scholarship · Journalism
Language and encodingCooperativeNatural languages · Writing systems · Mathematical and scientific notation · Data and code
Transmission and mediaOrganisedSpeech and conversation · Print and publishing · Broadcast media · Digital networks and platforms
Storage and memorySubstantiveLibraries and archives · Records and registers · Databases · Knowledge organisation systems, including this tree
Validation and discernmentOrganisedPeer review and replication · Rules of evidence · Editorial standards · Assessment and credentials
Machine-mediated informationOrganisedSearch and recommendation · AI systems that generate and retrieve · Automated agents

The information meta-cycle

Energetic-material throughput KnownSubstantive

The metabolism of civilisation: drawing energy and materials from the realms below, turning them into work and goods, and dissipating them as waste.

The framework's thesis Civilisation is metabolism: an economy is, at root, a system for distributing captured sunlight. Imagined · framework

Depends on

Energy extraction and conversionSubstantiveFossil fuels · Solar, wind and hydro · Nuclear power · Electricity grids
Materials extractionSubstantiveMining and quarrying · Forestry · Fisheries
Agriculture and food systemsSubstantiveCropping and soils · Livestock · Fertilisers and irrigation · Food distribution
Manufacture and constructionOrganisedFactories and industry · Buildings and cities
Waste and dissipationSubstantiveEmissions to air and water · Solid waste and plastics · Recycling and the circular economy

Energetic-material throughput

Production and exchange KnownCooperative

Reproducing the produced goods, the capital stock and the division of labour, with markets as one of several technologies for coordinating them.

Depends on

Work and the division of labourCooperativeOccupations and skills · Wages and the work relation · Unpaid and care work
Firms and enterpriseOrganisedBusinesses and co-operatives · Entrepreneurship · Management and operations
Markets and pricesCooperativeSupply and demand · The price signal · Competition and monopoly
Trade and logisticsCooperativeSupply chains · International trade · Transport
Physical capital and infrastructureSubstantiveMachinery and equipment · Infrastructure · Depreciation and maintenance

Production and exchange

The monetary-financial cycle KnownOrganised

The creation, circulation and destruction of money and credit: the ledger by which a civilisation records the claims its cooperation generates.

Depends on

Money creationOrganisedCentral banks · Bank lending creates deposits · Public money · Who receives new money first (the Cantillon effect)
Circulation and paymentCooperativePayment systems · Cash and digital money
Accounting and the ledgerOrganisedDouble-entry bookkeeping · Financial statements · National accounts and GDP · What the ledger cannot see Imagined · framework
Credit, debt and interestOrganisedLoans and repayment · Interest rates · Debt cycles and crises
Investment and capital marketsOrganisedShares and ownership · Bonds · Speculation and bubbles
Taxation and public financeOrganisedTaxes · Public spending · Public debt

The monetary-financial cycle

The technological cycle KnownOrganised

The invention, spread, upkeep and obsolescence of the methods by which a civilisation acts.

Depends on

Invention and designOrganisedEngineering design · Research and development
Diffusion and adoptionCooperativeAdoption curves · Standards and compatibility
MaintenanceSubstantiveRepair and upkeep · Skills that keep systems running
Obsolescence and replacementCooperativeWhat a new tool replaces Imagined · framework
Digital and computing technologyOrganisedComputers and chips · The internet · AI systems

The technological cycle

The political-institutional cycle KnownOrganised

Reproducing the rules, the legitimacy and the capacity for force through which collective decisions are made and enforced.

Depends on

Constitutions and law-makingOrganisedConstitutions · Legislation · Regulation
Legitimacy and consentOrganisedElections and representation · Rights and civil liberties · Public opinion · Political doctrines
Courts and adjudicationOrganisedCourts and judges · Due process
Force and securityOrganisedPolice · Armed forces · Sovereignty and borders
Administration and public servicesOrganisedThe public service · Local government
International orderOrganisedDiplomacy and treaties · International organisations · War and peace

The political-institutional cycle

The cultural-substrate cycle KnownSubstantive

The transmission and renewal of norms, discernment, meaning and trust from one generation to the next.

The framework's thesis It is the deepest and slowest cycle, on which all the others depend. Imagined · framework

Depends on

Norms, customs and kinshipCooperativeSocial norms · Custom and etiquette · Family and kinship forms
Meaning, belief and worshipSubstantiveLocated, not adjudicatedReligious traditions and practice · Sacred texts and their transmission · Ritual and festival · Theology
Ethics and moral discernmentSubstantiveLocated, not adjudicatedMoral traditions · Moral philosophy · Justice as collective discernment Imagined · framework
Arts and aesthetic traditionsCooperativeLocated, not adjudicatedLiterature and storytelling · Music · Visual art · Dance and theatre · Film and media arts
TrustSubstantiveCoherence of word, disposition and deed Imagined · framework · Trust in institutions
Cultural innovationOrganisedThe imaginative entrepreneur Imagined · framework · Diffusion of new ideas · Dissent and renewal
Identity and belongingCooperativeNational and ethnic identity · Group membership and its cost

The cultural-substrate cycle

The demographic-formational cycle KnownSubstantive

The reproduction of human beings and, inseparably, their formation into participants. Each person is born in the Ecological realm and formed in the Civilisational.

The framework's thesis Reproducing people bodily without forming them is the most decisive way a civilisation can fail to reproduce itself. Imagined · framework

Depends on

Birth, family and fertilitySubstantiveFertility and family size · Parenting and kin care
Care and upbringingCooperativeEarly childhood · Attachment and early care
Education and formationOrganisedSchools · Universities · Apprenticeship and vocational training · Credentials and the capacities they stand for Imagined · framework
Health and care systemsOrganisedHospitals and clinics · Public health · Disability and care
Migration and settlementCooperativeUrbanisation · Migration
Ageing, death and successionSubstantiveAgeing populations · Inheritance and succession

The demographic-formational cycle

Realm 3 · The threshold of agencyEcologicalLife: self-replicating systems shaped by selection. The realm where agency first appears from within, and the living engine that feeds every realm above.
Reproduction and heredity KnownElemental

Living things copy themselves, with variation, and develop from a single cell into a body.

Depends on

Genetic replication and variationElementalDNA and the genetic code · Mutation and recombination
DevelopmentElementalEmbryonic development · Growth and maturation
Epigenetic regulationElementalGene expression and its regulation · Inheritance of acquired marks across generations Speculative
Life cycles and generationsElementalBirth, maturity, reproduction, death · Generation time

Reproduction and heredity

Metabolism: the living engine KnownSubstantive

Life captures a fraction of the sun's flux and turns it into the food, fuel and oxygen that everything above depends on.

Depends on

PhotosynthesisSubstantivePrimary production · The oxygen atmosphere
Respiration and energy useSubstantiveCellular energy (ATP) · Burning food for work and heat
Maintenance and repairSubstantiveProtein turnover · Replacement of the body's atoms over years

Metabolism: the living engine

Physiology and health KnownSubstantive

The body as a set of coupled cycles kept in balance: stress, immunity, nutrition, sleep and ageing.

Depends on

Homeostasis and stressSubstantiveHormonal regulation · The stress response and its cumulative load
Immunity and diseaseSubstantiveImmune defence · Infectious disease and pandemics
Nutrition and growthSubstantiveDiet and growth · Malnutrition
Sleep and daily rhythmSubstantiveSleep · The circadian clock
Ageing and deathSubstantiveAgeing · Death

Physiology and health

Evolution by selection KnownCooperative

Inherited variation, sorted by survival and reproduction over generations, produces adaptation, new species and extinction.

Depends on

Variation and selectionCooperativeNatural selection · Sexual selection and costly signals
Speciation and adaptationCooperativeAdaptation · New species
Extinction and recoveryCooperativeMass extinctions · Recovery and radiation
CoevolutionCooperativePredator and prey arms races · Hosts and pathogens

Evolution by selection

Food webs and ecosystems KnownCooperative

Eating, partnering, decomposing and recovering: the undesigned order that moves energy and nutrients through living communities.

Depends on

Predation, grazing and competitionCooperativeFood chains and trophic levels · Keystone species
Symbiosis and mutualismCooperativePollination · The microbiome · Fungal networks in soil
Decomposition and nutrient returnCooperativeDecomposers · Nutrient recycling
Succession and disturbanceCooperativeFire, flood and recovery · Early and late succession
Ecosystem servicesCooperativeCrop pollination · Water purification · Soil fertility

Food webs and ecosystems

Populations and biodiversity KnownCooperative

How many of each kind of living thing there are, where, and how that changes.

Depends on

Population growth and limitsCooperativeCarrying capacity · Boom and bust
BiodiversityCooperativeSpecies diversity · Genetic diversity
Migration and dispersalCooperativeAnimal migration · Seed dispersal

Populations and biodiversity

Sensing, behaviour and the social animal KnownOrganised

Nervous systems, drives and social instincts: the deep inheritance every person carries into civilisation. Agency appears here, but not yet reflection.

Depends on

Nervous systems and sensingOrganisedNeurons and signalling · Perception
Emotion and driveOrganisedFear, care and separation distress · Play · Reward and craving
Bonding, hierarchy and cooperationCooperativeGrooming and alliance · Dominance hierarchies · Reciprocity and fairness · Us and them
Learning and animal cultureCooperativeImitation and emulation · Animal traditions
Signalling and deceptionCooperativeCostly signals and display · Self-deception

Sensing, behaviour and the social animal

Realm 2 · A settlement, not a lawPlanetaryEarth as one particular physical system. Its conditions are the contingent outcome of one planet's history, held in place by great cycles, and they could have settled otherwise.
Earth's physical givens KnownstandingElemental

The particular planet: its size, orbit, tilt, inner heat and magnetic shield, fixed by its formation and beyond any agency.

Depends on

Orbit, tilt and the seasonsElementalDay length and seasons · Orbital cycles behind the ice ages
Interior heat and magnetic fieldElementalRadioactive heat in the interior · The magnetic shield
Size, gravity and an atmosphereElementalGravity strong enough to hold an atmosphere

Earth's physical givens

The rock cycle and plate tectonics KnownSubstantive

Crust is made, moved, worn down and remade over millions of years. It supplies minerals, landforms, soils and the slow carbon thermostat.

Depends on

Plate tectonics and volcanismSubstantiveEarthquakes · Volcanic outgassing · Mountain building
Weathering and erosionSubstantiveChemical weathering · Erosion by water, ice and wind
Sedimentation and burialSubstantiveSedimentary rock · Coal, oil and gas: buried ancient photosynthesis
Soil formationCooperativeSoil: rock worked by life · Topsoil and its loss

The rock cycle and plate tectonics

The water cycle KnownCooperative

Water evaporates, falls, runs to the sea and freezes into ice, moving heat across the planet and fresh water onto land.

Depends on

Evaporation and transpirationCooperativeEvaporation from oceans · Transpiration by plants
Condensation and precipitationCooperativeClouds · Rain and snow · Monsoons
Rivers, lakes and groundwaterCooperativeCatchments · Aquifers · Floods and droughts
Ice sheets and glaciersCooperativeIce sheets · Sea level

The water cycle

Atmosphere, oceans and climate KnownCooperative

The circulation of air and sea and the planet's energy balance, which together hold the climate within a range life can use.

Depends on

Atmospheric circulation and weatherCooperativeWeather systems · Jet streams · Cyclones
Ocean currents and overturningCooperativeOverturning circulation · El Niño and La Niña
Greenhouse effect and energy balanceCooperativeGreenhouse gases · Albedo and ice feedbacks · Tipping points
The ozone layerCooperativeStratospheric ozone · Ozone-depleting substances

Atmosphere, oceans and climate

The carbon cycle KnownCooperative

Carbon moves between air, sea, living things and rock. Over long times it acts as the planet's thermostat.

Depends on

Fast carbon: photosynthesis and respirationCooperativeSeasonal breathing of the biosphere
Slow carbon: weathering and volcanismCooperativeThe long-term thermostat
Ocean uptakeCooperativeDissolved carbon · Ocean acidification
Fossil carbon releaseCooperativeEmissions from burning fossil fuels

The carbon cycle

Nitrogen, phosphorus and sulphur cycles KnownCooperative

The elements of life move through rock, soil, sea and living tissue and back again.

Depends on

The nitrogen cycleCooperativeBiological nitrogen fixation · Industrial fixation for fertiliser · Nitrate runoff and dead zones
The phosphorus cycleCooperativeWeathering of phosphate rock · Phosphate mining · Eutrophication
The sulphur cycleCooperativeVolcanic and industrial sulphur · Acid rain

Nitrogen, phosphorus and sulphur cycles

The planetary dashboard Knowndashboard

Nine readings of the planet's regulating processes, each in its own units and never summed into one number. Their status changes with each assessment, so read it live rather than from this tree.

The nine boundary processesClimate change · Biosphere integrity · Land-system change · Freshwater change · Biogeochemical flows · Ocean acidification · Atmospheric aerosol loading · Stratospheric ozone depletion · Novel entities

The planetary dashboard

Realm 1 · The realm of the givenCosmologicalUniversal physical law and the matter and energy it governs, the same in a star, a glacier, a cell and a phone.
Universal law KnownstandingElemental

The laws that hold everywhere and bind every realm above. Not a cycle but the given, which nothing above can alter.

Motion and gravitationElementalNewtonian mechanics · Conservation of momentum · Universal gravitation
Electromagnetism and lightElementalCharge and fields · Light and the electromagnetic spectrum · Electric circuits
Energy and entropyElementalConservation of energy · Entropy and the second law · Limits on the efficiency of any engine
Quantum mechanicsElementalAtomic structure · Quantum states and spectra · Solid-state physics
RelativityElementalThe speed-of-light limit · Mass-energy equivalence · Spacetime and gravity

Universal law

Matter and its transformations KnownstandingSubstantive

The elements, the bonds between them and the reactions that rearrange them: the material every realm above is made of.

Depends on

  • Universal law Chemistry is quantum mechanics and thermodynamics applied to atoms.
The elements and the periodic tableSubstantiveAtomic number and periodicity · Isotopes and radioactivity
Bonding and moleculesSubstantiveCovalent, ionic and metallic bonds · Molecular shape · Carbon (organic) chemistry
Reactions and equilibriaSubstantiveReaction rates and catalysis · Acids, bases and redox · Chemical equilibrium
States of matterSubstantiveSolids, liquids, gases and plasmas · Phase changes

Matter and its transformations

The stellar life cycle KnownCooperative

Gas clouds collapse into stars, stars forge heavier elements, and dying stars scatter them to seed the next generation. Every atom heavier than helium in your body passed through it.

Depends on

Star formationCooperativeMolecular clouds · Gravitational collapse
Fusion and nucleosynthesisCooperativeHydrogen fusion · Forging carbon, oxygen and iron
Stellar deathCooperativeSupernovae · Neutron-star mergers · White dwarfs
Recycling through interstellar gasCooperativeEnriched gas and dust · The next generation of stars and planets

The stellar life cycle

Cosmic structure and planetary systems KnownCooperative

Gravity gathers matter into galaxies, stars and planetary systems, including the one that made Earth.

Depends on

Cosmic originsCooperativeThe Big Bang model · The cosmic microwave background
Galaxies and their evolutionCooperativeGalaxy formation · Dark matter and dark energy Speculative
Formation of planetary systemsCooperativeProtoplanetary discs · Accretion of rocky planets
Orbits and tidesCooperativeOrbital mechanics · Tides

Cosmic structure and planetary systems

Energy flow and dissipation KnownflowSubstantive

Starlight flows outward and degrades into waste heat. Nearly every joule a civilisation spends is drawn from this one-way flow: the energy ceiling no growth can raise.

Depends on

Solar radiationSubstantiveSunlight reaching Earth · Sunlight as the source of food and fossil energy
Nuclear energySubstantiveFission · Fusion
DissipationSubstantiveWaste heat · Radiation back to space

Energy flow and dissipation

A person

The Cathedral's four kingdoms are the same four layers at the scale of one human being.

Imagined · framework

An institution or business

An institution is a small-scale bundle of the summit's cycles, set turning by a founder and kept turning by its members.

Imagined · framework
Where chemistry becomes biology
Biogeochemical cycles couple rock, air and sea with living activity. Soil is life worked into rock; the oxygen in the air is a product of life.
The carbon cycle · Nitrogen, phosphorus and sulphur cycles · Soil formation · Photosynthesis · Decomposition and nutrient return
Where biology becomes civilisation
Language, symbolic thought and cumulative culture let information be inherited beyond genes. Every person is born on one side of this line and formed on the other.
The demographic-formational cycle · Language and encoding · Learning and animal culture · The cultural-substrate cycle
Where civilisation meets its machines
Automated systems that act on representations. The open question of the fifth slot is a question about this interface.
Machine-mediated information · Digital and computing technology